A Lesson In Advertising From The Eighteenth Century

Back in the 1760s, the great Dr Samuel Johnson delivered himself of the dictum that 'promise, large promise is the soul of advertising'. It's a good thought, a great thought; and I contend that what was true then is equally true today. But it seems to me that modern advertisers are tying themselves into unnecessary knots in an attempt to reach audiences which they believe are becoming increasingly indifferent to their blandishments.

Well, yes, markets are turning deaf ears and blind eyes, but they always have done, though not for the reasons generally espoused by the world's marketers. I am convinced that despite all the sophisticated research and marketing effort that goes into advertising these days, the real reason that markets are indifferent to advertising is because much of it ignores the many splendoured principle that people don't buy products, they buy the benefits of owning those products.

Today, the great proportion of advertisers don't deliver sales messages, they tell what they hope are emotive stories with which the market can empathise, then they drop the product in as an afterthought, hoping that enough emotional cross-communication has been achieved for people to reach for their credit cards. That it doesn't and people won't has resulted in huge advertising budget cut-backs in the developed world in recent years. Only a manufacturer who has taken leave of his senses will throw even more money at a strategy that doesn't work.

The strategy responsible operates under the title Emotional Sales Proposition (ESP), thought in some quarters to be an advance on the Unique Sales Proposition (USP) which, on the contrary, does actually work. What has been overlooked or, more likely, ignored, is that in developing the principle of the USP in the late 1950s, the brilliant Rosser Reeves was striving to replace an advertising strategy that had been in situ for 30 or so years and was fast running out of steam. What was the device he was hoping to supersede? Well, by any other name, it was the emotional sales proposition. I won't bore you with the detail, but if you'd like to find out more, you should lay your hands on Reeves' book, Reality in Advertising (MacGibbon & Kee ? 1961). It could be an eye-opener.

So, it's true ? the one thing we learn from history is that we never learn anything from history. Let's go back to Dr Johnson. It's worth remembering that the kind of advertising old Sam was talking about in the 18th century was fairly innocuous and largely unexceptionable. It could be read in coffee- house flyers, in chapbooks and in rudimentary newspapers; and it consisted of sales messages as diverse as where to get your wig powdered and the date of the next public hanging at Tyburn. Even so, the products and services on offer were as important to the people of the time as mobile phones and computers are to us.

In the human condition, nothing much changes. Our egos still need to be massaged and we are all in hot pursuit of happiness. Only our methods for achieving these goals, only our technologies, vary with time.

So the next time you are tempted to commit advertising, think about Sam Johnson and give your market a reason for owning your product. A good reason.

About The Author

Patrick Quinn is an award winning copywriter with 40 years' experience of the advertising business in London, Miami, Dublin and Edinburgh. He publishes a FREE monthly newsletter, AdBriefing. Subscriptions are available at: http://www.adbriefing.com

Wall Street Journal
Spending Gap Between Search and Display Advertising Widens
Wired News - 15 hours ago
By Meghan Keane September 04, 2008 | 3:07:36 PMCategories: Advertising Online advertising spending may be growing at an annual rate of 20 percent but the ...
Gap Widens in Online Advertising Wall Street Journal
Verizon and Yahoo extend portal deal CNET News
Feature: Ad-supported software ZDNet.com.au
Motley Fool - BloggingStocksall 60 news articles

Direct Traffic Media
Obama, McCain have contrasting styles in Web advertising
Los Angeles Times, CA - 5 hours ago
By Jim Puzzanghera, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer It's been hard to avoid Barack Obama's distinctive red, white and blue "O" logo on display ads as you ...
Obama Expands Lead on McCain in Online Advertising Battle in June ... MarketWatch
Study says Obama beating McCain in online advertising Direct Traffic Media
Obama online advertising trumps McCain by 75:1 in June TG Daily
WebProNews - PC Magazineall 22 news articles

Mixpo Announces Online Video Advertising Pacts with Leading Local ...
Business Wire (press release), CA - 5 hours ago
Under the agreements, Mixpo’s new partners can leverage the company’s recently launched online video advertising platform to enable their advertisers to ...

Travelocity’s Roaming Gnome will vie for induction into Madison ...
Carolina Newswire (press release), NC - 1 hour ago
Since 2004 the Roaming Gnome, creation of Travelocity’s advertising agency McKinney, has traveled the world as the online travel leader’s “spokesgnome,” ...
BUSINESS BRIEFS Durham Herald Sun
all 2 news articles

Media not killing advertising – Ishiekwene
The Punch, Nigeria - 6 hours ago
By Olufemi Adeosun Senior media executives have debunked the notion that the media industry was killing the advertising business in Nigeria. ...

Calgary Herald
Latest James Bond flick criticised for glorifying armed violence
Oneindia, India - 6 hours ago
After British Advertising Standards Authority banned 'Wanted' posters in UK for glamorising the use of guns and violence, the Anti Gun campaigners want ...
jolie disarmed Toronto Star
Bond poster under fire from anti-gun campaigners Utalkmarketing
Wanted posters glamourising gun crime? Boxwish
AHN - TheCelebrityCafe.comall 198 news articles

dBTechno
Value Of Direct-to-consumer Drug Advertising Oversold, Study Finds
Science Daily (press release) - Sep 2, 2008
3, 2008) — Direct-to-consumer advertising may not be giving big pharma such a big bang for their buck after all. Despite the billions spent on bringing drug ...
Study says direct-to-consumer drug advertising notl that effective The Canadian Press
Consumer Drug Advertising Not Always Effective MedPage Today
Drugs advertising 'might not affect sales' Hays Pharma
AdAge.com (subscription) - Wall Street Journalall 88 news articles

www.companiesandmarkets.com: China Airport Advertising Industry ...
Trading Markets (press release), CA - 3 hours ago
In the airport advertising industry, with the scale of surpassing 1000, the practitioners communicate a lot. It is preliminarily estimated that outdoor ad ...

Cable to Fall Short on Advertising Revenue Goals, Pike & Fischer ...
MarketWatch - 20 hours ago
Cable executives have said they hope to increase advertising revenue from approximately $5 billion generated in 2007 to as much as $15 billion a year once ...

Nigeria: Critiquing branding and advertising
Global Voices Online, MA - 1 hour ago
by Ndesanjo Macha Jeremy critiques advertising, design and branding in Nigeria arguing that they are “extremely low in quality, with no demonstrable ...

Wind Chimes and more...

Windchimes for great gifts!

Latino Television Programs Fill a Void in Hispanic Advertising; While Advertisers Look to Attract