How To Give Criticism Without Bruising Egos

As responsible employers, parents, and friends, we have an obligation to correct the mistakes of other people in order to enhance their personal success. The task before us is how to correct a deficiency without damaging the delicate ego that can sometimes get in the way. Too often people criticize someone's behavior without providing a solution and this is detrimental because it then becomes a personal attack on the person that only aims to demerit them. Constructive criticism involves pointing out their weakness and offering a solution to correct it. In order to give constructive criticism, we must seek the solution to the problem before we point it out to the person. By doing this, we effectively separate the behavior from the ego and preserve the relationship in the process.

Here Are Some Strategies For Giving Constructive Criticism:

1. Never criticize while you are angry with the person. If your emotions are controlling your actions, then avoid any type of criticism. It becomes too easy to use that criticism as a chance to make a personal attack on the other person when emotions are high. Distance yourself and regain your own composure before you address a behavior that needs correcting.

2. Offer a better solution. Know the difference between disliking a certain behavior because it disagrees with your own personal preference versus disliking a behavior in favor of a more efficient way or correct way of doing something. Avoid making a criticism and then attempting to support it with emotional appeals because the issue then becomes a matter of personal preference and conflicting egos. Instead, use the power of logic to show the person that there really is a better way of doing the same thing that will enhance their own success and productivity.

3. Always let the person save face. This means respect the person, even if they did something completely inappropriate. The psychological consequences of embarrassing or disrespecting someone in front of their peers is very severe. It is so severe in fact, that such embarrassment has been a major factor in 80% of all violent incidents in the workplace and at schools. Criticism is a personal and private process that is not to be shared with anyone else. Also, it is just as important not to make it apparent to other people that you are giving, or going to give criticism. Asking someone to come into your office in front their peers can be just as damaging as criticizing them in public. Keep it very confidential and respect your counterpart's needs to save face in front of their peers.

4. Focus on the problem, not the person. When giving constructive criticism, make sure that you stay focused on addressing the problem and not the person. The problem is an objective issue that you can work cooperatively on to enhance both of your interests. Focusing in on the person, however, will always be construed as a personal attack against them-even if it is not meant to be. Personal attacks are always followed up with resentment and anger, which can actually be more detrimental in the long run because it can cause deep-seated resentment, which in turn, can lead to poor moral, clandestine or saboteur behavior, and passive-resistance. Remember that the person has feelings and those feelings can be easily broken by a wrong approach. Whenever you give criticism, follow the golden rule of attacking the problem, while being gentle on the person.

5. Empathize with their position. Empathy is the ability to step into the shoes of the other person and see the world from their perspective. Sometimes we forget what it is like to be the new person on the job because we have grown accustom to a certain procedure or routine that is second nature to us. Remember that people don't always see things as you do and part of being a good educator is being able to understand the other person's position and work with them at their level-not your own.

6. Never label the person. Attaching a negative label on the person being criticized is an inappropriate approach because it dehumanizes them, making it easier for you to be angry with them and it demoralizes them.

7. Focus on the future, not the past. Blaming someone for their past behavior does nothing but create conflict. The past is over with and your main concern is that it does not happen in the future. So instead of dwelling on past behavior, use it as a teaching tool so that they can improve in the future.

8. Use softening words to pad your criticism. Softening words are designed to "soften" harsh-sounding statements.. Softeners work because they leave a lot of room for interpretation of the statement that follows it. Some examples of softeners are, "I think," "I suppose," "it seems," "I believe," etc. So instead of making a harsh statement such as, "You're report is terrible." Replace it with a softened criticism such as, "It seems to me that this part of your report could use some revision." The psychological effect of rewording a statement can lead to a greater amount of persuasion and conflict avoidance.

9. Give them an opportunity to correct their behavior. This is an important step for any criticism because it works at two different levels. On the first level, giving them the opportunity to correct their behavior or actions lets them take responsibility for their behavior and reinforces the point that they must be held accountable for their actions. On the second level, giving them the opportunity to correct their behavior will give them an opportunity to redeem themselves and save face with you, which will make it easier for them to put their past behavior behind them and move one.

10. Constructive criticism is a sign of compassion. Criticism is often associated as a negative thing because it is often abused as a transport device for personal attacks. However, constructive criticism is a positive gift because the core message behind that criticism is that you care about the person enough to want them to succeed in the future. Constructive criticism is one of the main tests that separate regular people from true caring friends. Caring people will be honest with you and even risk generating conflict if they believe that their constructive criticism will help improve your life. Make sure that the person knows that your constructive criticism is done because you care about them and that you value your relationship with them. They will respect you more for being honest with them.

About The Author

Tristan Loo is an experienced negotiator and an expert in conflict resolution. He uses his law enforcement experience to train others in the prinicples of defusing conflict and reaching agreements. Visit his website at http://www.streetnegotiation.com or e-mail him directly at tristan@streetnegotiation.com

In The News:

---

Boston Globe
WTA tour to allow on-court tennis coaching
Telegraph.co.uk, United Kingdom - 19 hours ago
On-court coaching will be allowed at all women's tournaments next season, apart from the four grand slams, in a move that will not please the ...
WTA to Feature On-Court Coaching Washington Post
WTA approves coaching during matches San Francisco Chronicle
WTA Tour allows on-court coaching next year The Associated Press
Bob Larson Tennis News - New York Timesall 225 news articles

Carte seeks Riverside baseball coaching job
Daily Mail - Charleston, WV - 3 hours ago
by Rich Stevens CHARLESTON -- Former South Charleston head baseball coach Mike Carte has quietly served as an assistant for three years at Riverside. ...

Boston Globe
No Weekend Off for Irish Coaching Staff
Fighting Irish Insider - 5 hours ago
By Mike Frank While the Irish football team had the weekend off last weekend, the Irish coaching staff was once again very hard at work working on ...
Football Recruiting: Wood, Stockton highlight impressive 2009 ... Observer Online
Notre Dame still trying to return to prominence Gary Post Tribune
Countdown to Kickoff: Pat Kuntz’s new look WNDU-TV
Boston Herald - Bleacher Reportall 91 news articles

Los Angeles Times
Running games, coaching stability give AFC South the edge - NFL
ESPN - Sep 4, 2008
"I think with the Colts having won the division for five straight years, as a GM or a head coach, you have to build your team for that, like, ...
AFC South: Peyton's place on top Vancouver Sun
all 38 news articles

Game 2 better than Game 1? — Coaching cliche has ring of truth
Livingston Daily, MI - 8 hours ago
"It was hugely discouraging, considering how we performed in our scrimmage," said Pinckney coach Dan Burkholder, who expected much better from his team in a ...

MEN'S BASKETBALL: Cards finalize coaching staff
Ball State Daily News, IN - 21 hours ago
Newberry was promoted from director of basketball operations to an assistant coach Wednesday to finalize the Cardinals coaching staff for the upcoming ...

SkySports
Chappell takes on new coaching role in Australia
AFP - Sep 2, 2008
MELBOURNE (AFP) — Former India coach Greg Chappell has been appointed as the new head coach of the Cricket Australia (CA) Centre of Excellence in Brisbane. ...
Chappell to help Australia plot India's downfall Hindustan Times
all 291 news articles

Measuring the impact and value of executive coaching
Reliable Plant Magazine, OK - 3 hours ago
Executive coaching is a business strategy that is gaining favor in organizations that give serious attention to developing key talent. ...

Coaching clinics
MLive.com, MI - Sep 4, 2008
At the sites of two of the state's legendary basketball programs, there are coaching clinics coming up at Flint Central and Saginaw high schools, ...

Prerequisite to join legends: Title
Chicago Tribune, United States - 13 hours ago
Yet Smith's name is not mentioned along with Halas and Ditka when the franchise's coaching legends are hailed. Ditka, of course, guided the Bears to their ...
Better to be lucky than good? Bears are counting on it RosenBlog - Chicago Tribune Blog
Finding Tommie Harris' fountain of youth Chicago Tribune
No cause for optimism with Bears Chicago Tribune
all 10 news articles

coaching - Google News