E-Business: Domain Names - Bad Faith

Ian McMillan registered the internet domain name TrivialPursuits.net and won the right to continue using it, after a challenge from Horn Abbot, the makers of the board game, failed to stop him using the domain name. The makers of the Trivial Pursuits board game failed to obtain the TrivialPursuits.net domain name from the person who said he registered the name to lament life's loss of individual creativity.

This decision has gone against the long established principle that once a brand is "well known", the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP)1 part of the World Intellectual Property Organisation (WIPO), would be able to effect the transfer of the name. However, in this case, the panel was unclear about the intentions of the respondent, and his motive for registering the domain name. The panel did not believe that there was enough evidence to support an application for bad faith activity on behalf of the respondent.

Respondent Ian McMillan informed the WIPO panellist that he bought the name with with the intention of creating a website dealing with "the 21st Century's unique trivial pursuits, specifically the fact that most aspects of life now involve a commodity as opposed to individual creativity, from sex to salvation via surgery and sweeteners". Currently, the site is only one page long, and refers to the WIPO case as "a fine example of a quite unnecessary and utterly trivial pursuit," adding that more content will be added, "but at the convenience of my lazy nature."

There was little evidence of bad faith found by the panel, although McMillan does not appear to have intention of using the website.

Comment: Usually in cybersquatting cases where there "is no use of a sign in the course of trade" plus difficulty in establishing trade mark infringement or passing off, the UDRP approach is the recommended recourse as it is far cheaper and sometimes quicker.

If you require further information contact us.

Email: enquiries@rtcoopers.com

© RT COOPERS, 2005. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.

Rosanna Cooper is a partner in RT Coopers Solicitors. The firm is a full service commercial law firm covering areas such as E-Business, Education Law, Commercial Litigation, Data Protection, Intellectual Property, Corporate Finance and Commercial Contracts.

Contact us at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. visit our website at http://www.rtcoopers.com

Getting a domain name out of Network Solutions' clutches is much ...
NetworkWorld.com, MA - 23 hours ago
One of my domain names was registered long ago with Network Solutions. Network Solutions charges several times as much per year for registrations as other ...

Let's Talk Domain Names
AuctionBytes Blog, MA - Jul 19, 2008
The EcommBytes column in the July 20th issue of the AuctionBytes-Update newsletter tackles the issue of domain names. Let's talk! ...

After the
GulfNews, United Arab Emirates - 2 hours ago
In a major shake-up in Paris last month, the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (Icann) relaxed the rules on internet domain names that ...

Go Daddy to add Canadian Web-name registrar office
Arizona Republic, AZ - Jul 18, 2008
And though the office has just one employee, by August Go Daddy aims to be registering ".ca" domain names, the top-level domain for Canada. ...

Your Name on the Web: Choosing a Design Biz Domain Name
About - News & Issues, NY - Jul 18, 2008
Consider using a domain name that includes keywords that people are searching for like something with "graphicdesigner" or "logo-design" in the name. ...

China upgrades global domain name
People's Daily Online, China - Jul 18, 2008
The China Internet Network Information Center (CNNIC) officially launched "China's domain name global escalation action" on July 16, according to ...

Gillian Ferguson: Lions versus lawyers
Scotland on Sunday, UK - Jul 19, 2008
Tomorrow's prize is the domain name 'Narnia.mobi'. Purchased by us when the new '.mobi' suffix went on sale to the general public in 2006; all trademark ...

CNNIC Begins Global Chinese Domain Name Movement
RedlineChina, CA - Jul 18, 2008
The goal is to allow all domain names ending with “.CN� will be able to be shown by using the Chinese characters ‘??’(Zhong Guo), which means China. ...

Signs Point To 'Oklahoma City Thunder' As NBA Team Name
KOCO, OK - Jul 18, 2008
OKLAHOMA CITY -- The registrar for all of the NBA's Internet domain names reserved okcthunderbasketball.com on July 10, according to information gleaned ...

Dominating registrars' realm
Arizona Republic, AZ - 18 hours ago
The Scottsdale company, which sells and registers domain names to businesses and consumers, has grown its revenue 150 percent in the past two years. ...

Wind Chimes and more...

Windchimes for great gifts!

Detagged Domains