Creativity and Innovation Management ? Competition versus Collaboration -

Home
>
Business Management
>
Creativity and Innovation Management ? Competition versus Collaboration

Creativity and Innovation Management ? Competition versus Collaboration

There is much confusion as to whether competition or collaboration is most beneficial to creativity and innovation. Though there are negatives to collaboration and it is not easy separating the effects of time pressure and group activity, in general collaboration beats competition. This article will set out some of the arguments.

a) Competition forces some individuals to produce a greater number of ideas than they would do otherwise. But crucially, competition forces other people to shut down. Exactly who raises their game and who shuts down depends on the game, the rules, the competencies, the level of evaluation anxiety and other factors. People choose which areas they want to compete in.

b) When forced to produce, through competition, people are more likely to be non-synergistically extrinsically motivated ? that is they may produce to fulfil an ulterior motive but the activity leaves them feeling controlled and dependent and they do not tend to engage in the task to the degree necessary for rich insights.

c) Competition causes individuals to withhold information and thus reduces the degree of intellectual cross-pollination, networking and collaboration required to achieve the best ideas.

d) Most competition doesn't allow the mind to incubate problems long enough for truly rich insights to emerge. Some of the richest insights have occurred when the individual is distant from the problem, rested and engaged in unrelated activities.

e) Competition increases evaluation apprehension, which causes a reduction of expression and lower risk taking and higher levels of conformity. This is not conducive to good idea generation.

f) Competition causes individuals to generate ideas according to the value system indicated at the start, reducing lateral thinking, decreasing the number of diverse and novel ideas and lowering the separation of creative from critical thinking.

g) Collaboration is much more valuable during the innovation stage (idea selection, development and commercialisation), where the competencies of many people are required to successfully commercialise.

These topics are covered in depth in the MBA dissertation on Managing Creativity & Innovation, which can be purchased (along with a Creativity and Innovation DIY Audit, Good Idea Generator Software and Power Point Presentation) from http://www.managing-creativity.com. You can also receive a regular, free newsletter by entering your email address at this site.

Kal Bishop, MBA

**********************************

You are free to reproduce this article as long as no changes are made and the author's name and site URL are retained.

Kal Bishop is a management consultant based in London, UK. He has consulted in the visual media and software industries and for clients such as Toshiba and Transport for London. He has led Improv, creativity and innovation workshops, exhibited artwork in San Francisco, Los Angeles and London and written a number of screenplays. He is a passionate traveller. He can be reached on http://www.managing-creativity.com.

In The News:

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.sltrib.com/business/ci_11096321cid=1276221036ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNG2d5ezf8aCWp9WAE_1kK52Tao19AOn the Job: Working in lower position hones bmanagement/b skills/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fSalt Lake Tribune,nbsp;United Statesnbsp;-/font nobrNov 30, 2008/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1quot;Lower-rung jobs humble you and hone you,quot; says Facella, a top bmanagement/b guru. quot;You#39;re going to learn things you might not otherwise have had the chance to b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.networkworld.com/newsletters/dir/2008/120108id1.html%3Fhpg1%3Dbncid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNFL8TH0u0IcdfRthC4Sh-sqcDuK4gIdentity bmanagement/b heros and time-wasters/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fNetworkWorld.com,nbsp;MAnbsp;-/font nobr19 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1Dave Kearns provides the information you need to evaluate, install and maintain your corporate identity bmanagement/b system. A couple of weeks ago, b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.cmswire.com/cms/web-cms/2009-trends-in-saas-web-content-management-003583.phpcid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNHqSZBterMT02OGwhCVtOUEVU2Yaw2009 Trends in SaaS Web Content bManagement/b/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fCMSWire,nbsp;CAnbsp;-/font nobr16 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-12008 Our friends at CMS Watch recently announced their take on trends in SaaS Web Content bManagement/b for 2009. We#39;ve been contemplating about the future of b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.cobizmag.com/articles.asp%3Fid%3D2454cid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNFXJR8NqbXXOAQBsMlhcHhi8fkm-wThoughts from the Genghis Kahn school of bmanagement/b/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fColorado Biz,nbsp;COnbsp;-/font nobr12 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1I came across these facts and wondered how a man on horseback armed with a bow and arrows could possibly solve the bmanagement/b problems built into such an b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.networkworld.com/columnists/2008/120108backspin.htmlcid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNFp6HHOKL9oGJcERFdF3S4HQ2_XWgTough times and risk bmanagement/b, Part 2/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fNetworkWorld.com,nbsp;MAnbsp;-/font nobrNov 30, 2008/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1What I discussed in Part 1 was the need for a risk-assessment approach to IT bmanagement/b overall, not just to security. Reader Scott Crawford (Boulder, Colo. b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://news.thomasnet.com/fullstory/552436cid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNELZjE7vxyD5pHp_GpUGw4glfd6owSoftware facilitates general ledger bmanagement/b./abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fThomasNet Industrial News Room,nbsp;NYnbsp;-/font nobr16 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1Trintech Group Plc (NASDAQ:TTPA) is a leading global provider of integrated financial governance, transaction risk bmanagement/b, and compliance solutions for b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/News_by_Industry/Emami_plans_to_merge_Zandu/articleshow/3781356.cmscid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNETMaU2QGPWA4OKZ4DxhD1O6CzC5QEmami plans to merge Zandu, announces bmanagement/b rejig/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fEconomic Times,nbsp;Indianbsp;-/font nobr15 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1b.../b at merging Zandu Pharmaceuticals, which the company had recently taken over, while announcing a rejig in the top bmanagement/b of the acquired company. b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd width=80 align=center valign=topfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifa href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.rushprnews.com/2008/11/28/bureau-of-land-management-makes-a-turkey-of-a-deal-in-utah/cid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNETvWV6wtwMvNgmfFYv7_uCGd7wrAimg src=http://news.google.com/news?imgefp=SHqlxekGXuEJimgurl=www.rushprnews.com/press/wp-content/2008/11/tiltedrocks1.jpg width=80 height=70 alt= border=1brfont size=-2RushPRnews.com (press release)/font/a/font/tdtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/11/28/AR2008112802502.html%3Fhpid%3Dmoreheadlinescid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNHWT5Z4NYi98aJzH0vKBlpLSi5aRwUS Moves Ahead on Oil, Gas Leases on Public Land/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fWashington Post,nbsp;United Statesnbsp;-/font nobrNov 28, 2008/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1Over the last four fiscal years, a Washington Post analysis of Bureau of Land bManagement/b records shows, the government has dramatically accelerated the pace b.../b/fontbrfont size=-1a href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.latimes.com/news/printedition/asection/la-na-leases26-2008nov26,0,7874855.storycid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNFQaA_kv034J3JyXey9u5u5rqURqAAgency backs off from land auctions/a font size=-1 color=#6f6f6fnobrLos Angeles Times/nobr/font/fontbrfont size=-1a href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.rushprnews.com/2008/11/28/bureau-of-land-management-makes-a-turkey-of-a-deal-in-utah/cid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNETvWV6wtwMvNgmfFYv7_uCGd7wrABureau of Land bManagement/b Makes a Turkey of a Deal in Utah/a font size=-1 color=#6f6f6fnobrRushPRnews.com (press release)/nobr/font/fontbrfont size=-1a href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.sltrib.com/outdoors/ci_11072818cid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNH_jMNh6arfXX32xeNKwiVe15khzABLM backs off plan to issue drilling permits in Utah#39;s redrock country/a font size=-1 color=#6f6f6fnobrSalt Lake Tribune/nobr/font/fontbrfont size=-1 class=pa href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://blogs.tnr.com/tnr/blogs/environmentandenergy/archive/2008/11/27/a-thanksgiving-pardon-for-utah.aspxcid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNEUYRGVWqNamDKCfSruViS1KMPzZwnobrThe Plank on TNR.com/nobr/anbsp;- a href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://newsblaze.com/story/20081126063823zzzz.nb/topstory.htmlcid=1274375868ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNH0s7ATp1yN96pnQutiHmBLKje0ywnobrNewsBlaze (press release)/nobr/a/fontbr/font class=p size=-1a class=p href=http://news.google.com/news?sourceid=navclientie=ISO-8859-1rls=GGLG,GGLG:2005-22,GGLG:enncl=1274375868hl=ennobrall 233 news articles/nobr/a/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/management/article5269623.ececid=0ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNGlJSuuf_HzpjyrBU8XOLkcXESW5gbManagement/b briefing: Outplacement/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fTimes Online,nbsp;UKnbsp;-/font nobr9 hours ago/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1One industry, at least, is benefiting from the economic downturn, according to a report by Hardman amp; Co, the corporate research company. b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

table border=0 width= valign=top cellpadding=2 cellspacing=7trtd valign=top class=jfont style=font-size:85%;font-family:arial,sans-serifbrdiv style=padding-top:0.8em;img alt= height=1 width=1/divdiv class=lha href=http://www.citywebshopper.net/articles/includes/redirect.php?url=http://www.californiaprogressreport.com/2008/11/dorothys_law_to.htmlcid=1276278371ei=dN00SeiUCqGO6APuucTfDAusg=AFQjCNGiZQbR461ObVH3gprVoKHe6xh-2wDorothy’s Law: To Modernize Water Policy and bManagement/b in California/abrfont size=-1font color=#6f6f6fCalifornia Progress Report,nbsp;CAnbsp;-/font nobrNov 30, 2008/nobr/fontbrfont size=-1Hopefully some elected leader will follow Dorothy’s advice to move us towards sustainable water supply bmanagement/b. The text of the request for Dorothy’s Law b.../b/font/div/font/td/tr/table

management - Google News

Creativity and Innovation Management ? Competition versus Collaboration

Business Management