What Makes a Crisis a Crisis?

If you're old enough and were living in America about 30 years ago, you may remember the scandal in the motion picture industry known as "the Begelman affair" or "Hollywoodgate."

A skillful analysis of the crisis that rocked Columbia Pictures, a leading company in its field, is presented by Steven Fink in his book, "Crisis Management: Planning for the

Inevitable." I am telling the tale over, but not for the sake of relating a "juicy" story (such pastimes being hardly something I care for).

Rather, I believe there's a message for us here, primarily for business and professional people maybe, but also for husbands, wives, parents, educators - or mere "social animals". To paraphrase a popular saying, one real life case is worth a thousand sermons.

At the time our story opens, Columbia Pictures was riding the crest of the wave. Just about everything - profits, stock prices, reputation - was moving in one direction: UP.

For its president and CEO, Alan Hirschfield, things were looking pretty good, to say the least. He was loved by his family, admired by his peers, and respected by the thousands of employees under his command. He was very highly regarded in Wall Street. As for his material situation - well, comment is hardly necessary.

His right-hand man, David Begelman, head of the Columbia studio, wasn't doing too badly either. As one of Hirschfields most trusted and highly compensated employees, he was said to be

the man who actually ran the company in many ways. And as subsequent events indicated, many of his colleagues and associates thought the world of him.

Then the trouble started.

In early 1977, the accounting department sent actor Cliff Robertson an "IRS 1099" form. This official statement of earnings for tax purposes showed that the actor had been paid $10,000 by the studio the previous year. Robertson knew that this was incorrect, and asked his secretary to investigate.

A supervisor at Columbia looked up the Robertson file and found an endorsed check for $10,000 made out to Robertson. The signature on the back looked suspiciously like Begelman's...

Five months later, the matter reached the ears of Alan Hirschfield, and a question was raised with Begelman. The latter said he would take care of it. And he did.

Begelman told Cliff Robertson's accountant that a fictitious young man in Columbia's New York office had written a check to Robertson and forged his endorsement. As a result, the tax form had been issued in error, but certainly the Internal Revenue Service would be issued a correction. Of course, the youngster had been fired, and who'd have the heart to prosecute a kid...

There the matter might have rested, if not for Robertson's insatiable curiosity. How, he wondered, could a kid in New York have cut a company check, cashed it thousands of miles away, got away with forging the signature of a famous name, etc., etc...?

As Arthur Conan Doyle put in the mouth of the immortal Sherlock Holmes: " When you have eliminated all that is impossible, then whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth."

But in this instance, the stark truth wasn't something that the people at Columbia Pictures could easily come to terms with.

Could a man like Begelman have been so desperate to lay his hands on a "trivial" (in their eyes!) $10,000? Even if he was, he certainly didn't have to forge or embezzle to get an amount like that out of the studio. There were many easier, legitimate ways.

When Alan Hirschfield first confronted Begelman, only a small number of inner-circle people knew about the studio head's "indiscretion". If Hirschfield had fired him and rumors had began to circulate regarding the reason, Columbia could have stated openly with a clean conscience: as a result of some irregularities with company funds, Begelman had "resigned".

But, as author Fink points out, even this, only slightly uncomfortable, scenario need not have taken place. If Hirschfield had indeed fired Begelman at that early stage - as he surely should have - there could easily have been a jointly approved statement that nicely explained away the studio head's departure, without even hinting at the truth.

But Hirschfield missed that opportunity. Then, Begelman's many powerful friends on the board of directors started putting pressure on Hirschfield to give the man a second chance.

Begelman himself, having confessed to the embezzlement, begged for a second chance and said he would seek professional help.

Then three additional improprieties came to light, including a $35,000 contract and payment to a certain architect for acoustical work done on the motion picture "Tommy". In reality, Begelman had hired this architect to design a screening room in his home.

Hirschfield did make some attempts to oust Begelman, but the latter's friends on the board thwarted all of them. One day Begelman was out; next day he was back in again - either in his old position, or as an "independent producer" working with Columbia.

Finally, the media began snooping around.

All hell breaks loose

Now, all hell broke loose. The press went to town with "Holywoodgate", and the entertainment media had a field day, and more. Law enforcement agencies initiated investigations, and because Columbia is a public company, the Securities and Exchange Commission began one of its own.

Needless to add, the price of Columbia stock grew anemic. Talented people Hirschfield wanted to hire wouldn't dream of working at Columbia.

Hirschfield's own reputation plummeted, and his wife's moral character and integrity was impugned. There was no solid basis for the accusations, but it was an easy way to hurt her husband.

For Hirschfield, the Columbia crisis ultimately came to a head at a July 1978 board of directors meeting, when the board voted not to renew his contract. (Ironically, the very board members who had been grumbling about how Hirschfield was "running the studio, had been making it all but impossible for him to do so.

Fortunately for him, he soon bounced back to a new business career at Twentieth-Century Fox.) For the company itself, the climax came with its sale to Coca-Cola for $800 million.

And why did all this happen?

Because of one man's actions (Begelman's), yes. But even more so, because of one man's lack of action. If only Hirschfield had done the right thing at the right time...

What do you think? How would you have handled the situation in Alan Hirschfield's shoes? How would you have reacted as a member of the board?

More significantly - does this sad episode have a lesson for us? As entrepreneurs and managers? As employees? As spouses, parents or teachers?

Hopefully, you've never had contact with criminals, but does some aspect of this story ring a bell? Remind you of something in your life?

Azriel Winnett is the creator of Hodu. com - Your Communication Skills Portal. This popular website helps you to improve your communication and relationship skills on all levels, in business and professional life, in the family unit, and on the social scene. New articles added almost daily.

Teamwork Training: Learning to Build a Successful Team

Teamwork is a process that can be experienced outdoors and... Read More

Get Down With OCP: Evaluating DBA Job Applicants in an OCP World

Not long ago, weeding through DBA applicants with a tech... Read More

Three Professional Services Resolutions for 2005

With client expectations higher than ever before, and the gradual... Read More

Best Practices Plan: Dissemination of a Great Idea

Good news spreads quickly News of the invention of the... Read More

Why You Should Hold One More Meeting

If you are completely happy with where you and your... Read More

Five Reasons Why Leaders Fail to Create Successful Change

A bold title, don't you think? I mean, change is... Read More

Use QA As Your First Step To Outsourcing

Quality Assurance, or QA, is often given short shrift in... Read More

Behavioral Interview Questions You Can Use Monday Morning

If past behavior is the best way to determine future... Read More

Managing Meetings

Plan/prepare - lack of purpose causes aimless meetings. Know why... Read More

Tales from the Corporate Frontlines:Choosing an Effective Employee Recognition Program

This article relates to the Recognition competency, commonly evaluated in... Read More

Working with Hearing Impaired Employees - Giving Them a Fair Go

Hearing impaired people often encounter difficulty at work because their... Read More

Collaboration: 3 Keys to Keeping Your Documents from Getting Lost in the Shuffle

Often, collaborating documents in a team or in a business... Read More

IT Expenditure - Why Businesses Spend Huge Amounts on Ineffective IT Investments

Another IT White Elephant!It seems that almost every day we... Read More

Romford Accountants: Accountancy Firm Roles and Responsibilities

If you own or operate a business in the UK,... Read More

10 Ways To Work Through A Business Slowdown

In running any kind of business, it's inevitable that sometimes... Read More

Factoring Financing: How to Grow Your Business Without Debt or Loans

What is factoring?Accounts receivable financing, also known as factoring, is... Read More

Hiring and Retaining Good Employees

Hiring good employees is not only important to business, it's... Read More

How To Prevent Your New Manager From Becoming A Statistic

According to a study by the Manchester Group, 4 out... Read More

Competion or Cooperation?

It has been said, there is no better way to... Read More

Managing Employees Is A Little Like Herding Cats

Q: I started my small business about a year ago... Read More

The Professor Makes A Minus Power Move

If you think the power move has costs, consider the... Read More

No Time to Focus on the Big Picture? Try Focus Management

E-mail, voicemail, "got a minute?" interruptions, multiple projects... Read More

Hiring Great People And How to Be One Yourself: Five Secrets

Bad news.Your senior vice-president, your marketing director or your accounting... Read More

Problem-Solving Success Tip: Define the Problem First

Define the Problem First. It seems obvious, but how many... Read More

Are you NICE or do you CARE?

Are you NICE or do you CARE? ... Read More