Why Half of All Mergers Fail After the Honeymoon Ends

Marriages and corporate mergers in America have at least one thing in common, more than 50 percent end up on the rocks. In fact, according to a McKinsey study, only 23 percent ever recover the costs of walking down the corporate aisle. Another study showed that over 40 percent actually lose shareholder value.

These statistics should quell the corporate urge to merge, but, like young lovers, logic seldom gets in the way of romance.

A merger between families illustrates the difficulty of creating an ideal marriage. Two single parents, each with their own children, pets, and old habits, decide to marry and join their families into one.

Because mom and dad are so in love, they fail to see that the kids don't get along, the cat hates the dog, and their single TV can only handle one show at a time. Reality slowly begins to creep into paradise.

The cover of the February 7, 2005 issue of Fortune reads "Why Carly's Big Bet is Failing, referring to Hewlett Packers acquisition of Compaq. And the list goes on:

Take Bell Atlantic and Nynex. They are already experiencing resistance to change from some of their family. The Communications Workers of America have voiced concerns about this merger. Both companies appear to have different approaches to unions. Bell Atlantic appears more confrontational, while Nynex in recent years has tried to build stronger ties to the CWA. How this gets handled, might be the first test of who holds the remote control during prime time in this new family. Will the telecommunications giants work together to develop a strategy for working with the union? Or, will they leave things to chance?

Bell Atlantic and Nynex, was not the only engagement announced recently. Time Warner and Turner, Aetna and US Healthcare, SBC Communications and Pacific Telesis Group have promised to join hands as well. In each instance, the decision to merge makes good business sense. Bright people using sound data, keeping the interests of shareholders in mind, made these decisions. Unfortunately most of the attention will be on regulatory issue, finances, and grand organizational designs. The subtle and seemingly soft issues like how decisions get made may be left to chance. If so, this could be disastrous.

The betrothed companies will need to pay attention to the fact that they are attempting to blend different ways of working. I urge these companies to consider the following as they work on their wedding vows.

• How are decisions made? Do they come down from on high like lightning bolts from Zeus, or do people engage in a more democratic and slower process?
• How do people get things done? When an accountant needs to talk with her counterpart in marketing, must she go to her boss, who in turn talks to his peer, who in turn relays the message to her subordinate? Or do people just move freely in and out of departments with little formal regard for rank?
• What do communications systems look like? Does one company have an integrated management information system complete with e-mail and sophisticated intranet linkages, while its counterpart relies on pneumatic tubes, bulletin boards, and face-to-face contact?
• How are people rewarded in the two companies? Who gets bonuses, promotions, and coveted assignments? Does one company applaud risk taking and initiative while the other reveres people who play by the rules?
• What's punished? Is telling the truth like the child in the emperor's new clothes appreciated or does the speaker find he has just become a pariah?

Since each company believes that its way of operating is how God intended life to be in corporate America, major differences in culture could be difficult issues to face. It will important to persist. Typically, the more powerful partner prevails, but only at a cost. The "weaker" partner resists being told to change and this leads to subtle or profound resistance that hinders or stops efforts to merge operations. AT&T's purchase of National Cash Register was a disaster, in large part, because the far-larger parent company tried to inflict its culture on a company that was proud of its rich heritage.

There is a choice. The two companies can identify these differences. Recognize what's good about each culture and then determine jointly how they will face the future as a unified force. All these proposed mergers will face many tests to their cultures over the coming months. They can use these incidents as opportunities to examine differences and consciously select a way of working that fits the challenges they will face in coming years, or they can just hope they will live happily ever after.

Rick is an advisor to organizations on ways to lead Change without Migraines?. He is author of many books on change including Why Don't You Want What I Want? and Beyond the Wall of Resistance. You can access free articles and tools at http://www.beyondresistance.com.

Inhabitat
US government lifts ban on new solar plants
Dallas Morning News, TX - 13 hours ago
The US Bureau of Land Management announced on May 29 that it would forbid the construction of any new solar power plants on land it owns until it had time ...
Solar farms' impact to be explained Arizona Daily Star
Feds Lift Moratorium On US Solar Plant Applications Environmental Leader
Bureau Of Land Management Backpedals On Solar Moratorium Solar Industry
Slashdot - San Francisco Chronicleall 250 news articles

Management of Environmental Risk Exposures Hampered by Uncertainty ...
FOXBusiness - 18 hours ago
LONDON, Jul 04, 2008 (BUSINESS WIRE) ----The effective management of environmental risks is being hampered by a lack of certainty about the impact of ...

The Money Times
ISM Manufacturing Goes into Expansion Mode; AP Changes Subject
NewsBusters - 5 hours ago
On Tuesday, the Institute for Supply Management's Manufacturing Index, after four months of contraction, returned to slight expansion mode with a reading of ...
Service sector shrinks unexpectedly Reuters
From The Economist print edition Economist
Service sector shrinks in June - survey CNNMoney.com
MarketWatch - Reutersall 437 news articles

BBC News
Credit crunch: UBS piles $7.5bn on to its write-down bill
guardian.co.uk, UK - 12 hours ago
UBS said its wealth management/business banking and asset management divisions were profitable in the second quarter but conceded that it had seen an ...
Subprime-hit UBS says could break even second quarter AFP
ANALYSIS-UBS gets brief respite as strategic worries build Forbes
UBS Says It May Avoid Loss, Doesn't Need More Capital (Update2) Bloomberg
International Herald Tribune - TheStreet.comall 399 news articles

Lodging Hospitality Management to invest $9M in Collinsville hotel
Bizjournals.com, NC - Jul 3, 2008
Lodging Hospitality Management paid $5.3 million to the state of Illinois for the Collinsville Holiday Inn property in Collinsville, Ill., and is planning ...
State sells troubled Collinsville Holiday Inn to hotel management ... Belleville News Democrat
State unloads hotel after losing millions Chicago Tribune
Illinois to sell Collinsville Holiday Inn Tri County Journal
Dubuque Telegraph Herald - Belleville News Democratall 22 news articles

Disaster management tackle township floods
Independent Online, South Africa - 3 hours ago
By Bronwynne Jooste and Nwabisa Msutwana-Stemela The city of Cape Town's disaster management has assisted hundreds of families who were affected by the ...
Cape Peninsula braces itself for weekend floods SABC News
No flood evacuations in CT yet News24
Bad weather sets in for Cape Town SABC News
all 15 news articles

Telular Corp (WRLS) still held by Penbrook Management Llc
Mffais.com, CA - Jul 4, 2008
LONG BEACH (Mffais.com) - Penbrook Management Llc made no change in their 20000 shares in Telular Corp (WRLS) as shown by filings made public on 2008-07-03. ...
Synergetics Usa Inc (SURG) holdings reduced by Penbrook Management Llc Mffais.com
Stereotaxis Inc (STXS) holdings reduced by Penbrook Management Llc Mffais.com
Spectrum Pharmaceuticals Inc (SPPI) holdings reduced by Penbrook ... Mffais.com
Mffais.comall 55 news articles

Service Sector Data Adds to Inflation Anxiety
New York Times, United States - Jul 3, 2008
The Institute for Supply Management’s measure of employment in the vital service sector hit a record low, which could fan fears of a return to low growth ...
Service sector contracts as orders fall The Associated Press
Opening Glance: Shares of commercial banks slide Forbes
US services data snuffs out Europe stock rally Reuters
all 155 news articles

Author's Sought for Chapters in The Handbook on Knowledge ...
Emediawire (press release), WA - 3 hours ago
Washington, DC and India (PRWEB) July 5, 2008 -- PRWEB Author's working in telemedicine and knowledge management as researchers and practitioners are ...

Wabtec (WAB) holdings reduced by Country Fund Management
Mffais.com, CA - Jul 4, 2008
LONG BEACH (Mffais.com) - Country Fund Management sold -2022 (-9.53 %) of their shares in Wabtec (WAB), bringing their current holdings to 19178 shares as ...
Oracle Corp (ORCL) holdings reduced by Country Fund Management Mffais.com
Chesapeake Energy Corp (CHK) holdings reduced by Country Fund ... Mffais.com
Carter Inc (CRI) holdings reduced by Country Fund Management Mffais.com
Mffais.com - Mffais.comall 19 news articles

Wind Chimes and more...

Windchimes for great gifts!

50 Great Ways to Motivate and Not Break the Bank