Artificial Sweeteners - Are They Safe?

To research the health risks Sweet 'N Low and other artificial sweeteners I examined both sides of the story. There seems to be no neutral position on any of these sweeteners.

Sugar has become the #2 dietary concerns, following only fat content.

There are 3 general reasons for using artificial sweeteners; weight loss, dental hygiene, and for diabetics. Just like almost everything in life used in moderation there seems to be few health affects.

The reduction in calories comes from the lower quantity needed to add the sweet taste. Wanting something sweet is a natural reaction we are born with. Remember that sugar is a natural product and one that our body is able to metabolize from birth.

From a health standpoint I would rather use small amounts of sugar than manmade sweeteners. Better yet, as many doctors agree, wean yourself totally off of sweets. The more natural ingredients in our bodies the easier it is for our bodies to properly metabolize them.

The health risks of Sweet 'N Low appears to be the same as all of the artificial sweeteners. Too much is bad for you, a little is okay, and none is best.

For dieting purposes we are all going to use some type of artificial sweetener. As I keep repeating on this site you know your body better than anyone. If you notice any kind of side affect discontinue use for 2 weeks. Than try it again. If you still have any side affects try a different sweetener.

Let's start by listing the major artificial sweetener ingredients and which major brands use each.
Saccharin- FDA approved 1958- found in Sweet 'N Low (except Canada)
Cyclamate- FDA banned 1969- found in Sweet 'N Low (Canada only)
Aspartame- FDA approved 1981- found in NutraSweet and Equal
Sucralose- FDA approved 1999- found in Splenda
Neotame- FDA approved 2002- not found in many products yet
Xylitol- used in products for diabetics

The health risks of Sweet 'N Low are directly related to saccharin. Saccharin is 300 times as sweet as sugar. Being the oldest FDA approved sweetener in widespread use it has undergone many trials and tests. In the 1970's the FDA required warning labels. In 2000 the warning labels were removed. Bladder cancer is the major issue with saccharin. Canada has banned saccharin while allowing cyclamate. The U.S. banned cyclamate but allows saccharin. Both of these bans resulted from the same 1960's tests. Most nutritionists seem to agree that moderate use of saccharin causes no major health risk. Cancer found in lab animals resulted from very large doses of saccharin.

NutraSweet and Equal use aspartame as a sweetener. Aspartame is 160 times as sweet as sugar. It is more expensive than saccharin and not as sweet but it has a better taste. Many conditions have been blamed on aspartame but only one has been proven. Women with advanced liver disease or PKU (phenylketonuria) should never use aspartame. The sweet taste of aspartame is lost during cooking so do not use it in place of sugar in recipes.

NutraSweet has introduced another form of aspartame called neotame. It is very similar with 2 major exceptions. Neotame does not lose its sweet taste during cooking and there is no danger of PKU. At the current time there are very few products using it.

Sucralose is the sweetener used in Splenda. It is 600 times as sweet as sugar. Being the new kid on the block it is just now beginning to be scrutinized in greater detail. Dr. Joseph Mercola is leading the charge against sucralose. However the Center for Science in the Public Interest ranks it the safest of all sweeteners. Its claim that it is made from sugar seems to be true but not true. All resemblance to sugar is lost in the processing. There are 6 lawsuits saying just that and claiming false advertising. According to Dr. Mercola the FDA rushed sucralose into the approved category with only 2 trials being completed prior to approval. Apparently no tests were done on children or pregnant women. Everyone's body is different so metabolism rates vary greatly but at least 15% remains in your body. This is one sweetener I will keep monitoring and report any new developments. For now no side affects have been proven.

The sweetener Xylitol is more well known to those suffering from diabetes. It looks and tastes like sugar but does not require insulin in order to be metabolized because it is absorbed so slowly. It is also known as wood sugar because it originally came from birch. The sweetness is equal to sugar. Made popular in Finland the U.S. Army is going to start adding xylitol-sweetened gum to its MRE (meals ready to eat). It has actually been shown to have benefits to your teeth, including repairing small cavities. For those on a diet it should be said that xylitol has 40% less calories than sugar.

Although banned in the U.S., cyclamate, is the sweetener in the Canadian version of Sweet 'N Low. It is 30 times as sweet as sugar and leaves no after taste. The health risks of Sweet 'N Low in the U.S. is the same as those for cyclamate in Canada. Studies in the 1960's linked cyclamate and saccharin to bladder cancer in lab rats. The Canadians read the results one way while the U.S. read them another. Some manufacturers in the U.S. have asked for re-approval of cyclamate. There are 55 countries that have approved cyclamate sweetener.

While there is no concrete evidence of health risks of Sweet 'N Low or any of these sweeteners caution is advised. Low to moderate amounts of artificial sweeteners are acceptable. My problem with them is that every body is different. How do you know what low to moderate intake is for your body? With that said, my recommendation is the less you use the better it is for your health.

Hello, my name is Frank Keller and I am the owner of the Women's Health Supplements website. Don't be fooled by the name, we are not another vitamin retailer. All articles are not just reviewed by me they are written by me. From artificial sweeteners and bottled water to pregnancy nutrition every word is written to help you make an informed decision about your health. Content is chosen from your suggestions. Please visit us at http://www.womens-health-supplements.net to review our articles or to give us your recommendations for new articles. Healthy eating and a good nutrition plan takes very little of your time but is the single most important thing you can do for your health. Have a happy and healthy day!

National Dairy Council Makes $250 Million, Five-Year Commitment to ...
MarketWatch - 3 hours ago
The NDC will build upon their reputation as nutrition experts in schools, and become a key partner for the NFL on the league-wide health and wellness ...
Marketers just love football season USA Today
all 6 news articles

iNutrition.com's Sponsored Athlete Natalie Waples Wins IFBB Pro ...
Earthtimes (press release), UK - 5 hours ago
I want to thank the team of Natural Nutrition, iNutrition, and InterACTIVE Nutrition for all their support in my athletic endeavors -- this new Pro status ...

In the Matter of Continental Beverage and Nutrition, Inc.; Order ...
Trading Markets (press release), CA - 1 hour ago
... and Nutrition, Inc. ("Continental") because it has not filed any periodic reports since it filed a Form 10-QSB for the period ended November 30, 2006. ...

Nutrition Q&A: Quiz: Can you tell whether your food is safe?
The Olympian, WA - 1 hour ago
By GWEN SCHOEN | McClatchy Newspapers • Published September 05, 2008 While it's not truly a nutrition topic, knowing basic food safety is important when it ...

China Nutrition Market Report 2007 Report Reveals That China's ...
MarketWatch - Sep 3, 2008
Vitamin products are generally divided into two regulatory categories: vitamin pharmaceutical (OTC) and vitamin nutritional or functional foods. ...

Nutrition expert giving helpful tips
Downey Patriot, CA - 7 hours ago
DOWNEY—Home economist and nutrition expert Winifred Morice will speak at Downey Adult School on Sept. 18 as part of the regular OASIS meeting. ...

Exhibition to create awareness about nutrition to begin today
Thaindian.com, Thailand - 12 hours ago
New Delhi, Sept 5 (ANI): The Ministry of Women and Child Development will organise an exhibition on nutrition here today on the occasion of National ...

Berkeley restaurateur brings nutrition to fast food
East Bay Business Times, CA - 3 hours ago
Berkeley restaurateur Amanda West says it’s only natural that East Bay consumers start demanding more of their fast food. The 2005 Stanford University MBA ...

The Diet Detective Good fats vs. bad: Nutrition experts weigh in
Seattle Times, United States - Sep 3, 2008
We asked a few nutrition experts, and here are their answers. Is it true that you should not heat olive oil? According to Dr. David L. Katz, a professor at ...

Medical Nutrition USA to Announce Fiscal 2009 Second Quarter ...
MarketWatch - Sep 3, 2008
Please call in 10 minutes before the conference is scheduled to begin and ask for the Medical Nutrition conference call. After opening remarks, there will ...

Wind Chimes and more...

Windchimes for great gifts!

ACAI Berry Named Top 10 Superfoods For Anti-Aging by Dr. Nicholas Perricone